"Eight Lives Down" is a good book, especially if you like war stories. With better writing, it could have been a great book.
Chris Hunter spent four months in 2004 serving as a bomb disposal
specialist for British forces in Iraq. He survived explosions, rocket
attacks, and a wicked ambush. He risked his life defusing countless
bombs that could have killed and maimed many.
Hunter gives us
soldier's point of view of the Iraq War, and at times it's full of
heart-pounding tension and adrenaline-pumping fireworks. He offers up
fascinating details on the different types of bombs found in Iraq. He
also gives us a glimpse of the toll the war takes on soldier's personal
lives.
Hunter is certainly confident in his skills. On a few occasions in the book, this brims over into bragging.
While Hunter has some terrific stories to tell, they're too often
cluttered with impenetrable military jargon and abbreviations, as well
as British slang. If you're British or a military bomb disposal
specialist, this might not bother you, but for the average American
reader some of his sentences are almost incomprehensible.
Here's one: "We get the boys to help us transfer some EOD tools and
equipment into a couple of bergens, then, grabbing the ECM kit from the
new bleep, we chuck the whole lot into the back of a Warrior."
Or: "The sapper EOD teams are with us too-a hardy collection of Jocks, Scousers and Brummies."
I'm not sure it's fair to blame Hunter for this – he's a professional
soldier, after all, not a professional writer. His editor (he mentions
in the foreword having a U.S. editor) should have flagged these
items for rewriting.
There is a glossary at the end of the book
to help decipher some of the terms, but I didn't see it until I was
almost finished with the book. Still, editors should note this: If you
feel the need to include a glossary to make a manuscript understandable,
the book probably needs some rewriting.
That said, I learned
to skip over the jargon, abbreviations and slang, and they became less
of an annoyance as the book went on. Just keep pressing ahead, and
you'll find some enjoyable reading.
---
(Please support this blog by clicking on an ad, or by donating via
the Paypal button below.)
No comments:
Post a Comment