"Atom Smashers" attempts to make a difficult scientific topic interesting to a general audience, with only partial success.
The
documentary portrays the effort of scientists at Fermilab, near
Chicago, to find the "Higgs boson," a subatomic particle that – at the time – many
theorists believed to exist, but no one had actually found. (It was found in 2012.) Some
describe the Higgs boson as key to understanding life itself.
The strength of
the film lies in its portrayal of the scientists – dedicated,
passionate people who are unashamed nerds (they write songs using terms
from the Unix programming language). They're likeable
folks and they are committed to finding the Higgs boson, though not very
good at describing what it is.
As a viewer, you want to get
caught up in this quest, but the film does a poor job of explaining what the
scientists are doing. We see researchers planning experiments and we're
shown various charts and diagrams, but their significance is unclear. It's as if the filmmakers decided, "Particle physics is really complicated and hard to explain, so why bother trying?"
The other weak point in the
film is a clunky section in the middle in which the scientists whine
about dwindling government funding for their program. It was like a PBS
fundraising drive suddenly interrupting an otherwise engaging drama.
---
(Please support this blog by clicking on an ad, or by donating via
the Paypal button below.)
No comments:
Post a Comment